Happy First Birthday Power BI!

To mark the first anniversary of Power BI reaching RTM, Paul Turley and Adam Saxton have organised a celebration in the form of coordinated blog posts from the community and a video to say thank you to the Power BI team at Microsoft:

This has been a great year for Power BI and its success is a direct result of all of the hard work that the team have put in. Speaking personally, I am incredibly grateful for all the help and advice that I get on a daily basis from individual Microsoft employees who are often providing it in their own time. My congratulations to James Phillips and to everyone who has worked on Power BI to make it what it is today!

BI Survey 15

It’s BI Survey time again! BI Survey is the largest annual survey of BI users in the world, so if you want to share your feelings on Microsoft BI tools or whatever else you’re using then this is the opportunity to do it. As in the past, in return for promoting the survey I get access to the results when they appear later in the year, and they always make for interesting reading and a good blog post. This year I’m curious to find out what people are saying about Power BI…

Anyway, if you do want to take part (it should only take 20 minutes and you’ll also be entered in a draw for some Amazon vouchers) then here’s the link:


10th Blog Birthday

Earlier this year I celebrated 1000 posts on this blog; now it’s time to celebrate passing another milestone: ten years since my first ever post. Thanks to everyone who has been with me since then!

It’s my habit to post a review of the past year on this date, and as always there’s a lot to think about. This has been the first year where the majority of my posts have not been on SSAS or MDX. Most of my consultancy and training is still on these topics but given the lack of new features in SSAS recently it’s become harder and harder to find anything new to say about it (although a few other bloggers have managed to, such as Richard Lee’s great posts on using PowerShell to automate various SSAS administrative tasks). On the other hand I’ve invested a lot of time learning Power Query and as a result I’ve found a lot to write about, and this is true even after having written a book on it. I really hope that SSAS gets some attention from Microsoft soon – I’ve come to accept that I won’t see anything new in MDX, and the same is probably true of Multidimensional, but Tabular and DAX should get a major upgrade in SQL Server v.next (whenever that comes). Given the strong ties between SSAS Tabular, Power Pivot and now the Power BI Dashboard Designer I would guess that we’ll see new Tabular/DAX features appearing in the Power BI Designer in the coming months, and then later on in Excel and SSAS. When that happens I’ll be sure to write about them.

In the meantime, why the focus on Power Query? It’s not just to have something to blog about. If you’re a regular reader here you’ll know that I’m very enthusiastic about it and it’s worth me explaining why:

  • It solves a significant problem for a lot of people, that of cleaning and transforming data before loading into Excel. My feeling is that more people need Power Query for this than need Power Pivot for reporting.
  • More importantly, it’s a great product. It works well, it’s easy to use and I’m constantly being surprised at the types of problem it can solve. Indeed, where there’s an overlap between what it can do and what Power Pivot can do, I think users will prefer to work with Power Query: its step-by-step approach is much friendlier than a monolithic, impossible-to-debug DAX expression. Whenever I show off Power Query at user groups or to my customers it generates a lot of interest, and the user base is growing all the time.
  • I love the way that the Power Query dev team have released new features on a monthly basis. The amount that they have delivered over the last 18 months has put the rest of Power BI to shame, although I understand that because Power Query isn’t integrated into Excel in the way that Power View and Power Pivot are they have a lot more freedom to deliver. What’s more important though is that the Power Query dev team make an effort to talk to their users and develop the features that they actually want and need (the ability to set the prefix when expanding columns is a great example), rather than build whatever the analysts are hyping up this year. This gives me a lot of confidence in the future of the product.
  • Having seen the way that Power Query has been integrated into the Power BI dashboard designer, it could be the case that in the future the distinctions between Power Query, Power View and Power Pivot disappear and we think of them as parts of a single product.

One other big change for me this year was that I resigned from the SQLBits committee after seven years. There’s no behind-the-scenes scandal here, I just felt like it was time for a change. I work too hard as it is and I needed to free up some time to relax and be with my family; I was also aware that I wasn’t doing a great job on it any more. It was a very tough decision to make nonetheless. I had a great time with SQLBits while I was involved with it and I’ll be at SQLBits XIII in London next March as an attendee and hopefully a speaker. I know it will be another massive success.

Looking forward to next year, I hope the new direction for Power BI will be good for partners like me. There will certainly be continued interest in training for it, but the real test will be whether there’s a lot of demand for consultancy. I’ve done some Power Pivot and Power Query consultancy work this year, and demand is definitely increasing, but it’s still not a mature market by any means. Maybe the move away from Excel will change the nature of the BI projects that people attempt with Power BI, so that there are more formal, traditional implementations as well as the ad hoc self-service use that I’m seeing at the moment. The new Power BI APIs should also encourage more complex, IT department-led projects too. I don’t have a problem with the concept of self-service BI but I think it’s a mistake to believe that all BI projects can be completely self-service. I would like to think that there’s still a need for professional services from the likes of me in the world of Power BI; if there isn’t then I’m going to need to find another career.

Anyway, I’ve probably gone on for long enough now and I need to get back to enjoying what’s left of the holidays. Best wishes to all of you for 2015!

BI Survey 14 Results

Once again, the nice people at BARC have sent me a copy of the results of the latest BI Survey and allowed me to blog about some of their findings (obviously if you want to read them all, buy the survey!). Here are a couple of things that caught my eye:

  • When respondents were asked about which BI products they evaluated, Qlik came top of the list with 36% evaluating it, followed by all of the Microsoft products (Excel/Power BI at 35%, SSAS at 28% and SSRS at 26%). However when it came to picking products Excel/Power BI came top at 25%, followed by ‘other’ products, then SSAS at 21% and SSRS at 17% with Qlik at 16%. I wonder what parts of the Power BI stack the Excel/Power BI users were actually using exactly though? I suppose the point about it is that users can take whatever parts of it they want to complement what they do in Excel. These numbers are very encouraging in any case.
  • Looking at reported usage problems for MS products some familiar issues came up: 25% of Excel/Power BI users complained that the product couldn’t handle the data volumes they wanted and 16% complained of security limitations – both scores were the worst across all products. Partly this can be explained by the desktop-bound nature of the product, but I wonder whether the limitations of 32 bit Excel are behind the data volume problems? Also, 18% of SSRS users complained of missing key features, which again was the worst score for this category across all products. I hope MS plans to show SSRS some more love in the future after several years of neglect. Other products have other weaknesses of course – 26% of Tableau users had administrative problems, 53% of SAP BW users had problems with slow query performance and 21% of TM1 users had issues with poor data governance. Nothing is perfect.
  • Respondents were asked about cloud BI adoption. For those using Excel/Power BI, 15% were in the cloud now (the third best score across all products) which I assume means they are using Power BI for Office 365; a further 15% were planning to go to the cloud in the next 12 months; a further 19% were planning to go in the long term; and 51% had no plans. Presumably this last group of users would like to see more of the Power BI for Office 365 functionality implemented within SharePoint on premises.

Power Query Functions That Return Functions

You’re probably aware that, in Power Query, a query can return a function. So for example here’s a very simple query (so simple that no let statement is needed) called MultiplyTwoNumbers with the following definition:

(x as number, y as number) => x * y

It can be used on the following table in Excel:

…to multiply the numbers in the column called Number by two and show the result in a custom column like so:


Source = Excel.CurrentWorkbook(){[Name=”Data”]}[Content],

#”Inserted Custom” = Table.AddColumn(Source, “Custom”, each MultiplyTwoNumbers(2, [Number]))


#”Inserted Custom”

Here’s the output:

It’s also the case that a function can return another function. Consider the following query, called MultiplyV2:


EnterX = (x as number) =>


EnterY = (y as number) => x * y





It is a function that takes a single parameter, x, and it returns a function that takes a single parameter, y. The function that is returned multiplies the value of x by the value of y. Here’s an example of how it can be used on the table shown above:


//Return a function that multiplies by 2

MultiplyBy2 = MultiplyV2(2),

//Load data from the table

Source = Excel.CurrentWorkbook(){[Name=”Data”]}[Content],

//Use the MultiplyBy2 function in a custom column

#”Inserted Custom” = Table.AddColumn(Source, “Custom”, each MultiplyBy2([Number]))


#”Inserted Custom”

This gives exactly the same result as before:

In this query, the MultiplyBy2 step calls the MultiplyV2 function with the argument 2, and this returns a function that multiplies the values passed to it by 2. This function can then be called in the final step where the custom column is added to the table using the expression MultiplyBy2([Number])

Interesting, isn’t it? I hope this satisfies your curiosity Marco J

You can download the sample workbook for this post here.



Allocation in Power Query, Part 2

Last week’s post on allocation in Power Query caused quite a lot of interest, so I thought I would follow it up with a post that deals with a slightly more advanced (and more realistic) scenario: what happens if the contracts you are working with don’t all start on the same date?

Here’s the table of data that is the starting point for my examples:


I’ve made two changes:

  • I’ve added a contract name to serve as a primary key so I can uniquely identify each contract in the table. Several people asked me why I added index columns to my tables after my last post and this is why: without a way of uniquely identifying contracts I might end up aggregating values for two different contracts that happen to have the same number of months, contract amount and start date.
  • I’ve added a contract start date column which contains the date that the contract starts on, which is always the first day of a month.

Now let’s imagine that you want to make each monthly payment on the last day of the month. You need to take each contact and, for each monthly payment generate a row containing the date that is the last day of the month, containing the allocated payment amount.

Once again, having have opened the Query Editor the first step is to calculate the amount of the monthly payment using a custom column that divides Contract Amount by Months in Contract. This is shown in the Allocated Amount column:


Now to generate those monthly payment rows. Since this is reasonably complex I decided to declare a function to do this called EndsOfMonths inside the query, as follows:

= (StartDate, Months) =>
List.Transform(List.Numbers(1, Months), each Date.AddDays(Date.AddMonths(StartDate, _ ), -1))

This function takes the start date for contract and the number of months, and:

  • Uses List.Numbers() to create a list containing numbers from 1 to the number of months in the contract. For example if there were three months in the contract, this would return the list {1,2,3}
  • This list is then passed to List.Transform(), and for each item in the list it does the following:
    • Adds the given number of months to the start date, then
    • Subtracts one day from that date to get the payment date, which will be the last day of the month it is in

Calling this function on each row of the table in a new custom column (called Payment Date here) gives you a list of the payment dates for each contract:


All that you need to do then is to click on the Expand icon next to the Payment Date column header and make sure each column has the correct type, and you have your output for loading into the Excel Data Model:


Here’s the code for the query:


    //Load source data from Excel table

    Source = Excel.CurrentWorkbook(){[Name="Contract"]}[Content],

    //Add custom column for Allocated Amount

    InsertedCustom1 = Table.AddColumn(Source, "Allocated Amount", 

        each [Contract Amount]/[Months In Contract]),

    //Declare function for returning a list of payment dates

    EndsOfMonths = (StartDate, Months) => 

        List.Transform(List.Numbers(1, Months), 

            each Date.AddDays(Date.AddMonths(StartDate, _ ), -1)),

    //Call this function for each contract in a new custom column

    InsertedCustom = Table.AddColumn(InsertedCustom1, "Payment Date", 

        each EndsOfMonths([Contract Start Date], [Months In Contract]) ),

    //Expand the list

    #"Expand Payment Date" = Table.ExpandListColumn(InsertedCustom, "Payment Date"),

    //Set column data types

    ChangedType = Table.TransformColumnTypes(#"Expand Payment Date",

        {{"Contract Start Date", type date}, 

        {"Payment Date", type date}, {"Allocated Amount", type number}, 

        {"Contract Amount", type number}, {"Months In Contract", type number}})



There’s one more thing to do though. Since the Contract table contains real dates, it’s a very good idea to have a separate Date table in the Excel Data Model to use with it. I’ve already blogged about how to use a function to generate a Date table in Power Query (as has Matt Masson, whose version adds some extra features) and in that function (called CreateDateTable) can be reused here. Here’s a query that returns a Date table starting at the beginning of the year of the earliest start date in the contract table and ends at the end of the year of the last payment date:

    //Aggregate the table to find the min contract start date

    //and the max payment date

    GroupedRows = Table.Group(Contract, {}, 

    {{"Min Start Date", each List.Min([Contract Start Date]), type datetime}, 

    {"Max Payment Date", each List.Max([Payment Date]), type datetime}}),

    //Find the first day of the year of the min start date    

    #"Start Date" = DateTime.Date(Date.StartOfYear(GroupedRows{0}[Min Start Date])),

    //Find the last day of the year of the max payment date

    #"End Date" = DateTime.Date(Date.EndOfYear(GroupedRows{0}[Max Payment Date])),

    //Call CreateDateTable with these parameters

    DateTable = CreateDateTable(#"Start Date", #"End Date"),

    //Change data types

    ChangedType = Table.TransformColumnTypes(DateTable,{{"MonthNumberOfYear", type number}

    , {"DayOfWeekNumber", type number}})




You can now build a PivotTable to show the payments allocated over the correct ranges:


The sample workbook can be downloaded here.

Ninth Blog Birthday

This is the ninth anniversary of the first post on my blog, and every year at this time I take a moment to reflect on what’s happened in the last twelve months in my professional life and in the world of Microsoft BI.

Without a doubt 2013 has been the year of Power BI. It’s true we’ve had PowerPivot Power Pivot for a while now, but in my opinion the combination of Excel 2013, Power Query, Power Map, Power BI Sites and Q&A is a much stronger proposition for customers interested in self-service BI; I’ve already blogged at great length about what I think are the strengths and weaknesses of Power BI (see here, here and here) so I won’t repeat myself here. As you would expect Microsoft marketing has gone into overdrive to promote it (have you entered the Power BI competition yet?) and it will be in 2014 that we see whether Power BI is a success or not. What will success look like though, if it comes? It won’t be lots of customers lining up to buy Power BI in they way they’ve bought traditional BI solutions, I think: instead it will be organisations that have already signed up for Office 365 being upsold to Power BI based on their existing commitment to the Office platform. This presents a number of challenges to someone like me who makes a living as an independent consultant and trainer.

At the moment more than 90% of my consultancy income comes from SSAS and MDX, but the overall percentage of my time that I spend doing consultancy has reduced over the last few years to about 60%. This is partly the result of SSAS and MDX skills becoming more widespread; partly due to the fact that I’ve been promoting my public and private training more aggressively; and possibly due to fewer new SSAS projects kicking off. In the future I expect this trend to continue. Just how much consultancy will be necessary in the world of self-service Power BI solutions remains to be seen, but it’s going to be less than is necessary for corporate SSAS solutions and the rates will probably be lower too.

For the same reason, though, the demand for all forms of training for Power BI will almost certainly be much greater. That’s why I’ve been scheduling more public training courses through Technitrain; why I’ve signed up to write a book on Power Query next year; and why I’ve started recording video training courses with Project Botticelli (there’s a new video available there, by the way, on set and member functions). If I’m honest I prefer doing consultancy to training and I don’t think you can be a really good trainer if you don’t have a substantial amount of practical experience gained from consultancy, so I’m going to have to make a special effort to maintain a balance between the two.

Speaking at conferences and user groups is an aspect of my work that I’ve always really enjoyed, and I’m pleased to say that I’ll be speaking at the PASS BA Conference next year for example. I’m also still involved with SQLBits but please, please don’t ask me when the next SQLBits will be – we don’t have anything to announce yet but I can assure you we are working on it and I promise there will be one in 2014. I won’t be speaking at quite so many events as I have done in the past however. I travel a lot for work and this makes it hard to justify spending even more time away from my family, especially at weekends, so I’ve made a conscious decision to cut down on my speaking engagements. The thing is that the number of SQL Server events has increased a lot in the last couple of years and this has led to an increased number of invitations to speak, and I’m one of those people who finds it hard to say no when someone asks me to do something. I’m just going to have to be a bit more choosy from now on, and concentrate on events close to home, events that coincide with business trips and online sessions.

All that remains is to wish you all a happy and prosperous 2014, and to thank you for reading my blog! This time next year I’ll have been blogging for ten years, and that’s a scary thought…