Deprecated/Discontinued Functionality In SSAS 2014

Last week while reading Bill Anton’s blog (which is, by the way, highly recommended) I came across a link to a page in Books Online that I hadn’t seen before: a list of deprecated and discontinued functionality in SSAS 2014. Here it is:

The most interesting point is that the Non_Empty_Behavior property on calculations will not be supported in SSAS I still see this property being used a lot, and as I show here if you use it incorrectly it can give you bad results. Although I have seen a few cases where it has been necessary to set Non_Empty_Behavior (for example here) they have been very, very rare and I think deprecating it is the right decision. Other than that, remote partitions, linked dimensions and dimension writeback will also be no longer supported in a ‘future’ version, but I don’t think anyone will be too worried about those features.

Microsoft BI and SQL Server Courses For 2015

The Technitrain course schedule for 2015 has now been finalised, so if you’re looking for top quality Microsoft BI and SQL Server classroom-based training in central London why not check out what we’ve got coming up?

Rendering Images In An Excel Worksheet With Power Query Using Cells As Pixels

It’s a general rule of the internet that, whenever you have a cool idea, a few minutes spent on your favourite search engine reveals that someone else has had the idea before you. In my case, when I first saw the functionality in Power Query for working with binary files I wondered whether it was possible to read the contents of a file containing an image and render each pixel as a cell in a worksheet – and of course, it has already been done and done better than I could ever manage. However, it hasn’t been done in Power Query… until now.

First of all, I have to acknowledge the help of Matt Masson whose blog post on working with binary data in Power Query provided a number of useful examples. I also found this article on the bmp file format invaluable.

Second, what I’ve done only works with monochrome bmp files. I could have spent a few more hours coming up with the code to work with other file types but, frankly, I’m too lazy. I have to do real work too, you know.

So let’s see how this works. Here’s a picture of Fountains Abbey that I took on my phone while on holiday last summer:


I opened it in Paint and saved it as a monochrome bmp file:


Here’s the code for the Power Query query that opens the bmp file and renders the contents in Excel:

   //The picture to load
   //Or get the path from the output of a query called FileName
   //Load the picture

   //First divide the file contents into two chunks:
   //the header of the file, always 62 bytes
   //and the rest, which contains the pixels

   //Define the format as a record
    Header = BinaryFormat.Binary(62),
    Pixels = BinaryFormat.Binary()
   //Load the data into that format
   Overall = OverallFormat(SourceFile),
   //Get the header data
   HeaderData = Overall[Header],

   //Extract the total file size and
   //width and height of the image
   HeaderFormat = BinaryFormat.Record([
    Junk1 = BinaryFormat.Binary(2),
    FileSize = BinaryFormat.ByteOrder(
    Junk2 = BinaryFormat.Binary(12),
    Width = BinaryFormat.ByteOrder(
    Height = BinaryFormat.ByteOrder(
    Junk3 = BinaryFormat.Binary()
   HeaderValues = HeaderFormat(HeaderData),
   FileSize = HeaderValues[FileSize],
   ImageWidth = HeaderValues[Width],
   ImageHeight = HeaderValues[Height],
   //Each pixel is represented as a bit
   //And each line is made up of groups of four bytes
   BytesPerLine = Number.RoundUp(ImageWidth/32)*4,
   //Read the pixel data into a list
   PixelListFormat = BinaryFormat.List(
   PixelList = PixelListFormat(Overall[Pixels]),
   //Convert each byte to a number
   PixelListNumbers = List.Transform(PixelList, each Binary.ToList(_)),

   //A function to convert a number into binary
   //and return a list containing the bits
   GetBinaryNumber = (ValueToConvert as number) as list =>
     BitList = List.Generate(
      ()=>[Counter=1, Value=ValueToConvert], 
      each [Counter]<9, 
      each [Counter=[Counter]+1, 
      each Number.Mod([Value],2)),
     BitListReversed = List.Reverse(BitList)

   //A function to get all the bits for a single line
   //in the image
   GetAllBitsOnLine = (NumberList as list) => 
      List.Transform(NumberList, each GetBinaryNumber(_)
    ), ImageWidth),

   //Reverse the list - the file contains the pixels
   //from the bottom up
   PixelBits = List.Reverse(
    each GetAllBitsOnLine(_))),

   //Output all the pixels in a table
   OutputTable = #table(null, PixelBits)


The output of this query is a table containing ones and zeroes and this must be loaded to the worksheet. The final thing to do is to make the table look like a photo by:

  • Hiding the column headers on the table
  • Using the ‘None’ table style so that there is no formatting on the table itself
  • Hiding the values in the table by using the ;;; format (see here for more details)
  • Zooming out as far as you can on the worksheet
  • Resizing the row heights and column widths so the image doesn’t look too squashed
  • Using Excel conditional formatting to make the cells containing 0 black and the cells containing 1 white:image


Here’s the photo rendered as cells in the workbook:


And here it is again, zoomed in a bit so you can see the individual cells a bit better:


You can download the workbook (which I’ve modified so you can enter the filename of your bmp file in a cell in the worksheet, so you don’t have to edit the query – but you will have to turn Fast Combine on as a result) from here. Have fun!

A Closer Look At Power Query/SSAS Integration

In the November release of Power Query the most exciting new feature was the ability to connect to SSAS. I blogged about it at the time, but having used it for a month or so now I thought it was worth writing a more technical post showing how it works in more detail (since some things are not immediately obvious) as well as to see what the MDX it generates looks like.

This post was written using Power Query version 2.18.3874.242, released January 2015; some of the bugs and issues mentioned here will probably be fixed in later versions.

Connecting to SSAS

Power Query officially supports connecting to all versions of SSAS from 2008 onwards, although I’ve heard from a lot of people they have had problems getting the connection working. Certainly when I installed the version of Power Query with SSAS support in on my laptop, which has a full install of SQL Server 2014, it insisted I install the 2012 version of ADOMD.Net before it would work (I also needed to reboot). My guess is that if you’re having problems connecting you should try doing that too; ADOMD.Net 2012 is available to download in the SQL Server 2012 Feature Pack.

After clicking From Database/From SQL Server Analysis Services the following dialog appears, asking you to enter the name of the server you want to connect to.


If this is the first time you’re connecting to SSAS the following dialog will appear, asking you to confirm that you want to use Windows credentials to connect.


Unfortunately, if you’re connecting via http and need to enter a username and password you won’t be able to proceed any further. I expect this problem will be fixed soon.

Initial Selection

Once you’ve connected the Navigator pane appears on the right-hand side of the screen. Here you see all of the databases on the server you’ve connected to; expand a database and you see the cubes, and within each cube you see all of the measure groups, measures, dimensions and hierarchies.


The previous build of Power Query does not display any calculated measures that aren’t associated with measure groups (using the associated_measure_group property); this has been fixed in version 2.18.3874.242.

When you start to select measures and hierarchies the name of the cubes you have chosen items from will appear in the Selected items box. If you hover over the name of the cube the peek pane will appear and you’ll see a preview of the results of the query.


At this point you can either click the Load button to load the data either to the worksheet or the Excel Data Model, or click the Edit button to edit the query further.

You cannot specify your own MDX query to use for the query as yet.

The Query Editor

Once the Power Query Query Editor opens you’ll see the output of the query as it stands, and also on the Cube tab in the ribbon two new buttons: Add Items and Collapse Columns.


Here’s the MDX (captured from Profiler) showing the MDX generated for the query in the screenshot above:

{[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount],[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]}
on 0,
[Date].[Calendar Year].[Calendar Year].allmembers
,{[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount],[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]})
properties member_caption,member_unique_name 
on 1 
from [Adventure Works]


The MDX Subset() function is used here to ensure that the query doesn’t return more than 50 rows.

Adding Items

Clicking on the Add Items button allows you to add extra hierarchies and measures to the query. When you click the button the following dialog appears where you can choose what you want to add:


In this case I’ve added the Day Name hierarchy to the query, and this hierarchy appears as a new column on the right-hand edge of the query after the measures:


You can easily drag the column to wherever you want it though.

Here’s the MDX again:

{[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount],[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]}
on 0,
[Date].[Calendar Year].[Calendar Year].allmembers,
[Date].[Day Name].[Day Name].allmembers)
,{[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount],[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]})
properties member_caption,member_unique_name 
on 1 
from [Adventure Works]


Collapsing Columns

Selecting the Day Name column and then clicking the Collapse Columns button simply rolls back to the previous state of the query. However, there’s more to this button than meets the eye. If you filter the Day Name column (for example, by selecting Saturday and Sunday as in the screenshot below) and then click Collapse and Remove, the filter will still be applied to the query even though the Day Name column is no longer visible.


Here’s what the Query Editor shows after the filter and after the Day Name column has been collapsed:


Compare the measure values with those shown in the original query – it’s now showing values only for Saturdays and Sundays, although that’s not really clear from the UI. Here’s the MDX generated to prove it – note the use of the subselect to do the filtering:

{[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount],[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]}
on 0,
[Date].[Calendar Year].[Calendar Year].allmembers
,{[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount],[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]})
properties member_caption,member_unique_name 
on 1 
({[Date].[Day Name].&[7],[Date].[Day Name].&[1]})
on 0 
[Adventure Works])


From studying the MDX generated I can tell that certain other operations such as sorting and filtering the top n rows are folded back to SSAS.

It’s also important to realise that using the Remove option to remove a column from the query does not have the same effect as collapsing the column:


Using Remove just hides the column; the number of rows returned by the query remains the same.


User Hierarchies

In the examples above I’ve only used attribute hierarchies. User hierarchies aren’t much different – you can select either an individual level or the entire hierarchy (which is the same as selecting all of the levels of the hierarchy).



Parent-Child Hierarchies

Parent-child hierarchies work very much like user hierarchies, except that you will see some null values in columns to accommodate leaf members at different levels:


M Functions

There are a lot of M functions relating to cube functionality, although the documentation in the Library Specification document is fairly basic and all mention of them disappeared from the online help a month or so ago for some reason. Here’s the code for the query in the Collapsing Columns section above:

    Source = AnalysisServices.Databases("localhost"),
    #"Adventure Works DW 2008" = Source{[Name="Adventure Works DW 2008"]}[Data],
    #"Adventure Works1" = #"Adventure Works DW 2008"{[Id="Adventure Works"]}[Data],
    #"Adventure Works2" = #"Adventure Works1"{[Id="Adventure Works"]}[Data],
    #"Added Items" = Cube.Transform(#"Adventure Works2", {
             "[Date]", {"[Date].[Calendar Year].[Calendar Year]"}, {"Date.Calendar Year"}}, 
             {Cube.AddMeasureColumn, "Internet Sales Amount", 
             "[Measures].[Internet Sales Amount]"}, 
             {Cube.AddMeasureColumn, "Internet Order Quantity", 
             "[Measures].[Internet Order Quantity]"}}),
    #"Added Items1" = Cube.Transform(#"Added Items", {
              {Cube.AddAndExpandDimensionColumn, "[Date]", 
             {"[Date].[Day Name].[Day Name]"}, {"Date.Day Name"}}}),
    #"Filtered Rows" = Table.SelectRows(#"Added Items1", each (
             Cube.AttributeMemberId([Date.Day Name]) = "[Date].[Day Name].&[7]" 
             meta [DisplayName = "Saturday"] 
             Cube.AttributeMemberId([Date.Day Name]) = "[Date].[Day Name].&[1]" 
             meta [DisplayName = "Sunday"])),
    #"Collapsed and Removed Columns" = Cube.CollapseAndRemoveColumns(
             #"Filtered Rows", 
             {"Date.Day Name"})
    #"Collapsed and Removed Columns"

It’s comprehensible but not exactly simple – yet another example of how difficult it is to shoe-horn multidimensional concepts into a tool that expects to work with relational data (see also SSRS). I doubt I’ll be writing any M code that uses these functions manually.

Multiselect, Filtering And Functions In Power Query

If you’re a Power Query enthusiast you’re probably already comfortable with creating functions and passing values to them. However in some scenarios you don’t want to pass just a single value to a parameter, you want to pass multiple values – for example if you are filtering a table by multiple criteria. What’s the best way of handling this in Power Query?

Imagine that you wanted to import data from the DimDate table in the SQL Server Adventure Works DW database. It’s a pretty straightforward date dimension table as you can see:


Imagine also that you didn’t want to import all the rows from the table but just those for certain days of the week that the user selects (filtering on the EnglishDayNameOfWeek column).

The first problem is, then, how do you allow the user to make this selection in a friendly way? I’ve already blogged about how the function parameter dialog can be made to show ‘allowed’ selections (here and here) but this only allows selection of single values. One solution I’ve used is to create an Excel table – sourced from a Power Query query of course – and then let users select from there.

In this case, the following query can be used to get all the distinct day names:

    Source = Sql.Database("localhost", "adventure works dw"),
    dbo_DimDate = Source{[Schema="dbo",Item="DimDate"]}[Data],
    #"Removed Other Columns" = Table.SelectColumns(dbo_DimDate,
																							{"DayNumberOfWeek", "EnglishDayNameOfWeek"}),
    #"Sorted Rows" = Table.Sort(#"Removed Other Columns",
                                    {{"DayNumberOfWeek", Order.Ascending}}),
    #"Removed Duplicates" = Table.Distinct(#"Sorted Rows"),
    #"Removed Columns" = Table.RemoveColumns(#"Removed Duplicates",
    #"Added Custom" = Table.AddColumn(#"Removed Columns", "Selected", each "No")
    #"Added Custom"

Nothing much interesting to say about this apart from that it was all created in the UI, it shows the day names in the correct order, and it has an extra column called Selected that always contains the value “No”. The output table in Excel looks like this:


The Selected column is going to allow the end user to choose which days of the week they want to filter the main table by. Since “Yes” and “No” are going to be the only valid values in this column you can use Excel’s Data Validation functionality to show a dropdown box in all of the cells in this column that allows the user from selecting one of those two values and nothing else.



Once the user has selected “Yes” against all of the day names they want to filter by in the Excel table, the next step is to use this table as the source for another Power Query query. To be clear, we’ve used Power Query to load a table containing day names into an Excel table, where the user can select which days they want to filter by, and we then load this data back into Power Query. This second query (called SelectedDays in this example) then just needs to filter the table so it only returns the rows where Selected is “Yes” and then removes the Selected column once it has done that:

    Source = Excel.CurrentWorkbook(){[Name="DistinctDates"]}[Content],
    #"Filtered Rows" = Table.SelectRows(Source, each ([Selected] = "Yes")),
    #"Removed Columns" = Table.RemoveColumns(#"Filtered Rows",{"Selected"})
    #"Removed Columns"


This query doesn’t need to be loaded anywhere – but it will be referenced later.

With that done, you need to create a function to filter the DimDate table. Here’s the M code:

(SelectedDays as list) =>
    Source = Sql.Database("localhost", "adventure works dw"),
    dbo_DimDate = Source{[Schema="dbo",Item="DimDate"]}[Data],
    #"Filtered Rows" = Table.SelectRows(dbo_DimDate, 
                             each List.Contains(SelectedDays,[EnglishDayNameOfWeek]) ) 
    #"Filtered Rows"

The thing to notice here is the condition used in the Table.SelectRows() function, where List.Contains() is used to check whether the day name of the current row is present in the list passed in through the SelectedDays parameter.

The final step is to invoke this function and pass the column from the query containing the selected days to it. There is a bit of UI sugar when you invoke a function with a parameter of type list that I blogged about recently. In this case when you invoke the function you just have to pass the pass it the EnglishDayNameOfWeek column from the SelectedDays query.


Here’s what the code for the query that invokes the function looks like:

    Source = DimDate(SelectedDays[EnglishDayNameOfWeek])

And of course, when you run the query and output the results to a table, you get the DimDate table filtered by all of the days of the week you have selected:


To change the output the user just needs to change the selected days and then refresh this last query.

In case you’re wondering, this query does get folded back to SQL Server too. Here’s the SQL generated by Power Query:

select [$Ordered].[DateKey],
    select [_].[DateKey],
    from [dbo].[DimDate] as [_]
    where [_].[EnglishDayNameOfWeek] in ('Monday', 'Wednesday', 'Friday')
) as [$Ordered]
order by [$Ordered].[DateKey]

Notice that the Where clause contains an IN condition with all of the selected days.

You can download the example workbook for this post here.

Bidirectional Relationships And Many-To-Many In The Power BI Designer

There’s a lot of cool stuff in the new Power BI Designer desktop app, but for me the most important new bit of functionality is one that’s not immediately obvious: relationships between tables in the data model have had a significant upgrade. Let me illustrate…

Bidirectional Relationships

First up: relationships can now filter in two directions. Consider the following two tables in an Excel workbook, a dimension table called Fruit and a fact table called Sales:


When you first load these tables into the Power BI Designer no relationships are created between the tables. To create relationships you need to click on the Manage button on the Home tab so that the Manage Relationships dialog appears. You can then click the Autodetect button and the relationship between the two FruitID columns is created.


However, click on the Edit button and you’ll see something interesting. In the Edit Relationship dialog, under Advanced options, you’ll see that the Cross filter direction is set to Both (the other option is Single).


This means that, not only can you create a report like this with FruitName field on rows axis of a table in a Power View report along with a measure showing the sum of values from the Sales field:


But you can also now take the Date field from the Sales table and put it on rows in the report along with a measure showing the distinct count of values from the Fruit Name field from the Fruit table:


The relationship between the two tables is working in both directions, from the dimension table to the fact table and from the fact table to the dimension table, which is a big change from Power Pivot in Excel where a relationship can only work in one direction (from the dimension table to the fact table). You can still get the original Power Pivot relationship behaviour by setting the Cross filter direction property to Single.


If you thought that was impressive, there’s another implication of this change: many-to-many relationships now work automatically. No nasty DAX is necessary – which is lucky because, at the time of writing, there’s nowhere to use DAX in the Power BI Designer. Here’s the same data as above but with two more tables, so that there is now a classic many-to-many model with a dimension table called Group and a factless fact table called GroupToFruit associating each fruit with one or more groups and each group with one or more fruit.


Here are the relationships in the model, all of which were created using the Autodetect button and all of which have their Cross filter direction set to Both:


And here’s what you see in a report when you put GroupName on rows with a measure showing the sum of Sales:


The sales value for Berries is 35, the sum of the sales for Raspberries and Strawberries; the sales value for Red Fruit is the same because that group contains the same fruit; but the grand total is not the sum of the groups but the total sales for all fruit.


Anyone that has tried to build a reasonably complex model in Power Pivot or SSAS Tabular will understand how big a change this is. Up to now if you wanted to use many-to-many relationships you needed to add extra DAX code to each measure you created, and that added an unwelcome layer of complexity; now it just works. I haven’t thought it through properly yet but I bet that many other modelling scenarios can now be solved with this new functionality too. Time to do some thinking…